Owen did not like that answer.
But Lily studied me, serious and quiet.
That means you won’t lie,” she said.
“No,” I said. “I won’t lie.”
She stepped forward and hugged me.
It was sudden, brief, and so careful that it broke my heart. Her arms touched my shoulders as if she expected to be told she had done it wrong.
I froze for half a second.
Then I wrapped one arm around her gently.
Owen watched.
Then he stepped in too, Captain pressed between us.
For one minute, the noise of O’Hare disappeared.
There was only the weight of two children who had been left behind and the terrible privilege of being someone they had decided, for reasons I did not deserve, might come back.
When Maya led them away, Owen turned three times.
Lily turned once.
I stood there until they disappeared through the sliding doors.
Marco did not speak.
Good.
If he had, I might have broken something.
That night,
I did not board my flight.
I returned to my penthouse overlooking the city and found it exactly as I had left it—silent, spotless, expensive, empty.
The lights came on automatically as I entered.
Floor-to-ceiling windows reflected a man in a dark suit with tired eyes and a jaw clenched too tightly. Beyond the glass, Chicago glittered under a low ceiling of clouds. Cars moved along Lake Shore Drive like streams of red and white light.
I poured a glass of water and left it untouched.
At midnight, Elise arrived carrying a folder.
She had a key. She used it only when she had decided my permission was unnecessary.
“You look awful,” she said.
“You always know what to say.”
“It’s a gift.”
She set the folder on the kitchen island. “Preliminary information. Public records only, plus what I could get through appropriate channels.”
“Elise.”
“I said appropriate, and I
mean appropriate.”
I opened the folder.
Evan Bennett.
Age thirty-eight at death.
Occupation: forensic accountant.
Cause of death: single-car accident on a rural road outside Lake Forest.
Survived by spouse, Claire Bennett, and minor children, Lily and Owen Bennett.
Previous spouse: Anna Vale Bennett. Listed as deceased in one filing, absent in another. No death certificate included.
I looked up. “What does that mean?”
“It means something is inconsistent.”
“Anna may be alive?”
“It means I don’t have proof she’s dead.”
“Find it.”
“I’m trying. Carefully.”
I turned the page.
Evan had no sister.
No aunt Rebecca.
No family friend listed.
One brother: Nathaniel Bennett.
Last known address: Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
Phone disconnected.
“Why would Claire tell them he didn’t want them?”
“Maybe he didn’t,” Elise said. “Maybe he couldn’t be found. Maybe Claire didn’t try.”
I looked at the accident report summary.
Road conditions clear.
No other vehicles involved.
No
signs of intoxication reported.
Investigation closed.
Something about it felt thin.
“What was Evan working on when he died?”
Elise sighed. “Ryker.”
“He was a forensic accountant.”
