I scrolled through them with detached curiosity, like reading about someone else’s life.
Hudson: “Where are you? This isn’t funny anymore.”
Hudson: “Call me immediately. We need to talk about this.”
Hudson: “People are asking questions I can’t answer.”
Vivien: “Isabella, whatever point you’re trying to make, you’ve succeeded. Go home and fix this.”
Vivien: “This is beyond selfish. You’re embarrassing the whole family.”
Cousin Cynthia said, “Hudson says he had a family emergency. Is everything okay?”
Aunt Margaret: “Darling, we’re worried about you. Please call someone and let us know you’re safe.”
I almost laughed at the last one. Now they were worried about me. After five years of watching me work myself to exhaustion for their benefit, now they were worried about my safety.
I took another sip of my mai tai and opened my camera app. The sunset behind me was turning the sky into shades of orange and pink that seemed too beautiful to be real. I snapped a selfie, making sure to capture both my genuinely happy expression and the paradise backdrop.
Then I sent it to Hudson with a message I had been composing in my head for the past eight hours.
“Thanksgiving dinner in paradise. Tell Vivien the turkey is her problem now.”
The answer came in a matter of seconds. My phone rang immediately. I let it go to voicemail. Then I turned my phone off completely and ordered another mai tai.
By 8:00 pm, the great Thanksgiving disaster had reached legendary status within the family. Half the family had gone out in search of restaurants that might still be serving food. The other half had gathered in the kitchen, trying to salvage something resembling a meal from the chaos Hudson and Vivien had created.
Uncle Raymond had taken charge of the turkey situation, declaring that they could cut up the birds and cook the pieces separately to speed things up. Cousin Julie was trying to make mashed potatoes from scratch while consulting YouTube tutorials. The Sanders family had left altogether, citing food safety concerns and their son’s allergies.
Hudson sat at the kitchen table, looking at Isabella’s text message for the hundredth time. Each time, the reality became more surreal and devastating. She wasn’t coming back. She hadn’t been kidnapped or hospitalized or forced to handle someone else’s emergency. She had made the decision to leave them all behind, and she was clearly enjoying every minute of it.
“This is what happens when you spoil someone too much,” Vivien announced from the room as she tried to salvage the green bean casserole. “Give them too much freedom and they think they can abandon their responsibilities whenever they want.”
But even as she said it, her voice lacked its usual conviction, because somewhere in the chaos of the day, the impossible nature of what they expected Isabella to accomplish had become clear. It had taken six adults four hours just to put the turkeys in the oven and start three side dishes. What Isabella had been doing alone year after year was beginning to look less like a wifely duty and more like a minor miracle.
You will find the rest on the next page.
“Perhaps we should have helped her more,” Uncle Raymond said quietly as he struggled to figure out how to properly season the turkey pieces.
“Help her?” Vivien’s voice was high-pitched. “She never asked for help. She always insisted on doing everything herself.”
Hudson looked up from his phone.
“She asked me for help two days ago,” he said, his voice strangely flat. “I told her I was too tired of golf.”
The kitchen fell silent, except for the sound of boiling water and the timer tilting in the oven.
“She asked for help on Tuesday,” Hudson continued, her voice growing louder as the memory cleared. “She told me she needed real help, not just carving the turkey. And I told her she was a better cook than I was.”
He could see the scene now with painful clarity: Isabella’s exhausted face, her hands raw from hours of food preparation, her desperate plea for royal assistance, and his casual dismissal of her needs because helping would have been an inconvenience to him.
“She has been asking for help for years,” said Carmen’s voice from the doorway .
Hudson looked up to see his sister-in-law standing there with a container of food and a barely contained expression of anger.
“Carmen, what are you doing here?”
“I brought sweet potato casserole, since I thought you might need some real food.” She slammed the container on the counter a little harder than necessary. “I also came to tell you what I should have told you years ago.”
She looked around the room at the assembled relatives, all of whom had stopped their cooking attempts to listen.
“Isabella didn’t abandon you,” Carmen said, her voice cutting through the noise of the kitchen. “You abandoned her. All of you. For five years, you’ve watched her work herself to death for your comfort. And none of you ever thought to say, ‘Hey, maybe one person shouldn’t be responsible for feeding thirty-two people alone.’”
“Now wait a minute,” Vivien began.
